oPg Gaming Forum
February 07, 2012, 01:38:21 PM *
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Make payments with PayPal - it's fast, free and secure!
News: Stay tuned to opggaming.com for new features, modifications, and improvements.
 
   Home   opggaming Help Arcade Search Calendar stats SourceBans Login Register  


hd-gaming
Pages: [1]   Go Down
  Print  
Author Topic: Critique this please...  (Read 381 times)
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Latro
Guest
« on: January 18, 2007, 09:18:16 AM »

So I wrote this in another thread really quickly, but I've always been interested in learning how a writer would view a short tale like this.  What is missing?  What's good?  Where can I improve? What makes you want to stop reading?

Be honest, I can't be offended... Here is the memory I wrote:

This one time in third grade I went over to a friends house... and as we were getting off the bus, he turned to me and said "Are you ready to run?" At first I was confused and stared at him blankly so he quickly said "Just run as soon as the bus door opens."

I learned why we were running before the door had fully opened, right as I looked up to get off the bus when from the trees close by came a hissing sound and then a sudden pain on my forehead that felt like a bee sting.  A few chuckles echoed from the trees and I instantly knew the threat.  OLDER BROTHERS!   I ran faster than I had ever ran before but it wasn't fast enough.  Following the blow to my forehead, pellets hit my hand, and then my knee, a couple bounced off of my backpack, and then one got me, right in the back of the head...

The impact startled me and I tripped on a rock and fell head first into the bushes next to the front porch of my friends home.  Dazed but still somewhat startled I turned and looked at my friend as he ran through the door slamming it behind him, the sound of pellets bouncing off the door starting to bring me back to reality.

The pellets shifted from the door and then started again to bounce off of me as I pulled myself to my knees and crawled up the steps.  When I was close enough to grab the knob, the door opened slightly.  It all happened so fast it was like a blur, I thought at first it was my friend coming to drag me into safety, but I was wrong.  His German Shepard quickly pounced on me and knocked me backwards down the steps.  "Sick Him, Sick Him" came from the open door but it wasn't my friend's voice I heard.  The dog growled and barked but never attacked me.  Then the laughing starting.. From the bushes, from the doorway, and suddenly all 3 of his older brothers were there helping me up and into the house.  Inside the house my friend was stuck on the stairway in pain from a massive wedge he just experienced from the oldest brother hiding inside, waiting if either of us happened to escape the pellet attack.

Logged
sarahstaby
Guest
« Reply #1 on: January 18, 2007, 10:20:51 AM »

Oh boy.  You don't know what you're asking for.  Ha ha.  Well, here is my amateur take on it.  This is a delightful story, actiony, love the punch at the end.  Oo, so glad I wasn't you, sounded very unpleasant.  The pace flows pretty well.

I went through and dissected everything I could think of, just because I have nothing better to do at the moment.  Take my advice with a grain of salt; use what you like, ignore what you don't.


(This opening works perfectly for its purpose here, but if you were to use this as a short story anywhere else you might want to change it to ?In third grade I?? or ?When I was in third grade I?? etc.)  This one time in third grade I went over to a friends (friend?s) house... and as we were getting off the bus, he turned to me and said "Are you ready to run?" At first I was confused and stared at him blankly (I am a fan of adverbs, but the pros really look at them.  Using too many is automatic amateur stamp.  You have six in here.  Use them when you feel you must; avoid them when you can.  It?s hard, but an effective way to get around using them is to find a verb that does the job.)  so he quickly said (this one, for example, could be hissed, uttered, cried, whatever.) "Just run as soon as the bus door opens."

I learned why we were running before the door had fully opened, right as I looked up to get off the bus when from the trees close by came a hissing sound and then a sudden pain on my forehead that felt like a bee sting.  (This sentence is long.  If you read it out loud it kind of drags on and leaves you confused.  Here?s a suggestion:  I looked up as the bus doors opened.  Something hissed from the nearby trees, then a sudden pain on my forehead like a bee sting.) A few chuckles echoed from the trees and I instantly knew (to get rid of this adverb try replacing ?instantly knew? with something like ?realized? or ?understood?.  The reader will still understand that it was a quick thing.) the threat.  OLDER BROTHERS!   I ran faster than I had ever ran (run) before but it wasn't fast enough.  Following the blow to my forehead, (You can cut this first part out so the sentence looks like this: ?Pellets hit my hand, my knee, a couple bounced off my backpack, and then one got me, right in the back of the head??)pellets hit my hand, and then my knee, a couple bounced off of my backpack, and then one got me, right in the back of the head...

The impact startled me and I tripped on a rock and fell head first into the bushes next to the front porch of my friends home.  (This one is long too.  During the more exciting parts, sentences can be shorter.  It gives a story a staccato effect, helps the sentences move at the same pace as the story.  Put a period after ?startled me?.  Here?s a suggestion for the next line:  ?I tripped on a rock, falling head first into the bushes next to his front porch.?) Dazed but still somewhat startled(,) I turned and looked at my friend as he ran through the door(,) slamming it behind him,(.) (The sound of pellets bouncing off the door started to bring me back to reality.) the sound of pellets bouncing off the door starting to bring me back to reality.

The pellets shifted from the door and then started again to bounce off of me as I pulled myself to my knees and crawled up the steps.  When I was close enough to grab the knob, the door opened slightly (to get rid of ?slightly?, ?the door opened a crack?).  It all happened so fast it was like a blur,(.) I thought at first it was my friend coming to drag me into safety, but I was wrong.  His German Shepard (shepherd) quickly pounced (Pouncing is a quick action.  You don?t even need ?quickly? here.)on me and knocked me backwards down the steps (?on me, knocking me??).  "Sick Him, Sick Him" came from the open door(,) but it wasn't my friend's voice I heard.  The dog growled and barked but never attacked me.  Then the laughing starting..(started,) from the bushes, from the doorway, and suddenly all 3 of his older brothers were there (you can cut ?there?) helping me up and into the house.  Inside the house my friend was stuck on the stairway in pain from a massive wedge (wedgie) he (had?)just experienced from the oldest brother hiding inside, waiting if either of us happened to escape the pellet attack.


 Cheesy Can you believe I did all that?
Logged
Latro
Guest
« Reply #2 on: January 18, 2007, 10:56:43 AM »

This is exactly what I was hoping for. Thanks for the thoughts!  I feel the only way to improve is for someone to show you how things look from a different perspective. 

For me, I often see the thoughts or actions in my mind but coming up with the words to describe them the way I see it can be difficult.

Since I speak another language, I really struggle now since there are some things that English doesn't have a word for that another language describes perfectly...
Logged
mactombs
Moderator
Jr. Member
*****
Posts: 70



WWW
« Reply #3 on: January 18, 2007, 03:44:41 PM »

Ooh, good critique. I don't think I can be more helpful. Your story reminds me of a friend I had growing up. He lived near a farmer's plot and every time he'd lose a ball or something in the plot, when he went over to get it back, the owner of the plot was waiting with a pellet gun loaded with salt pellets. (Ouch?)

Something I learned recently (from Writing Tools) that helps me, as far as constructing sentences that flow, is to watch where I put my subject and verbs. In that last sentence I put them at the end and used a passive verb to link them (not a good example of good writing). If you seperate your subject and verb, the sentence will be more confusing. You can build suspense by putting the subject at the end of the sentence, but for clarity, being upfront helps. Build sentences from left to right. Think of the sentence as a train where the subject is the locomotive and it pulls the rest of the sentence (cars) after it. Punctuation is the caboose! (<-- mine was bright red there)

It helps to know quickly what subjects, nouns, pronouns, verbs, adverbs, adjectives, and so forth are when dissecting sentences that don't sound right. I'm not so good at this, but I imagine that if you know a foreign language, dissecting subjects and verbs isn't something you're foreign to.

Reading stuff out loud also helps, since if it sounds awkward to say, it's probably awkward to read.
Logged

...shamelessly exceeding the federal mandate in sexitude...
sarahstaby
Guest
« Reply #4 on: January 19, 2007, 11:55:00 PM »

I didn't know which way was up until I was able to get some feedback about my writing.  I learned about a lot of my mistakes just by finding them in other people's work.  I had no idea how much room I had to grow (and still have to grow).  Anyway, I don't speak a different language, and I still struggle to find words that fit the descriptions in my head.

Some days are easier than others.
Logged
Pages: [1]   Go Up
  Print  
 
Jump to:  

Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.12 | SMF © 2006-2009, Simple Machines LLC | Sitemap Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!


Google visited last this page January 01, 2012, 01:44:25 PM